American Idol 4/14

I don't care what they said about George. Even though I hate that song as much as Quentin, he made it listenable.

Ya know what? I'm not going to say who I think should leave. I'm going to say who i think should stay.

George, Fantasia, LaToya, Jennifer.

In the immortal words of Shake-Man...

The End

I think it was George's worst performance. but i voted for him anyway. Fantasia was pretty fabulous.

I agree with mare. After tonight I could easily give the boot to everyone BUT Fantasia, Layoya, and Jennifer. I like George too, but I think those 3 girls are better. I also agree that George's song wasn't as bad as all the judges made out. To me, it showed his softer side, why does everything have to be funky with him? I think people have put him in THEY'RE rut!

I think every one did pretty well tonight. Once again I'm hoping Jon Peter is voted out because I agree with Simon, he may be fun to watch but he doesn't have the best voice. The way the voting has been lately I'm not counting on him leaving soon. My guess is that it might be Diana's last night. John Stevens picked a great song that matched his voice well. I agree with everyone that Fantasia, LaToya, George and Jennifer did great.

My bottom three would be: John Stevens, George and Jasmine.

Please, please, please let it be John Stevens who goes tonight

I thought it was one of the best nights yet. I LOVED LaToya!!! She just seems to have it all. I really thought they all did a pretty good job. I think Diana is adorable, and I always enjoy her performances. Unfortunately, America doesn't seem to agree with me. Based on previous votes, I think Diana and Jasmine will be the botton two. John Stevens couldn't have picked a better song for his voice. He's no 'American Idol', but he sure could make it in the business doing songs like that. As usual, I'm hoping JPL will go, but as perviously stated, America doesn't always agree with me. All in all, I loved last night's show!!

Pksoz....you really liked it last night??? Oh wow - I thought it was boring!!! Fantasia just ROCKED. Wow. But everyone else??? Blah.....

So many sappy movie songs, so many mediocre performances...

But damn, Fantasia was BEYOND fantastic this week.

Quentin was the best guest judge yet, and the first to do anything besides dig to find something good to say to the contestants. I had to laugh when he said to George, "You made me forget I hate that song." My sentiments exactly.

I guess I'm just a sucker for 'show tunes'!! So long, JPL!! Tonight, I think America got it right.

Yeah! The voters came to their senses and voted out JPL

Yeah I wanted just one more week of JPL and one less week of bouncy, cutsie Diana, but boy did he leave rockin' out!

I'm glad John Stevens will get to sing Barry Manilow. Another theme right up his alley.

Mare "Could This Be The Magic at Last?" Rivera

JPL is gone?

And double because now that I know I won't have a conflict between watching Survivor and the AI results show.

I have come to a startling revelation...





I've got a crush on Simon

I could not contain my glee when the 2 Jons were the bottom 2! One down, one to go!